Very early in my career as a journalist, I made a silly mistake at work that very nearly had a serious commercial consequence for the company I was working for. It was nothing malicious or even intentional - I’d simply failed to fact check something properly, and the mistake made it to print.
My manager could have shown me the door. Instead, I got some grace, and the mistake became a lesson in checking my work properly, and double checking it when needed.
I think about that moment whenever I hear that Gen Z is lazy or not ready for work. I wasn’t ready for work either. I was new and I got something wrong. Thankfully, somebody was prepared to teach me.
I recently came across a video on YouTube video called “Why Employers Hate Gen Z” that got me thinking about this again. It opens with a US survey finding that six in ten employers have fired a recent graduate shortly after hiring them. It then follows a fictional new hire, a composite named Sofia, through her first 77 days. Sofia has no written expectations and a manager with too many direct reports to teach anyone, and she ends up being fired without being clearly told what went wrong.
I can’t help wondering what would have happened if I’d been starting my career today. Would my manager have taken the time to help me learn from that mistake? Or would I have become another example of a young employee like Sofia who supposedly wasn’t ready for work?
Gen Z is entering a difficult job market, with AI changing the kinds of entry-level roles that have traditionally helped people develop their skills. Rather than asking how we can better prepare young people for work, we seem increasingly willing to blame them when they struggle.
Forget wondering if Gen Z is ready for the workplace. Are we giving them what they need to be ready and to succeed?
Every generation gets the same treatment
One of the most frustrating aspects of this conversation is that it’s far from a new one. Every generation seems to get the same treatment.
I’m Gen X, or more accurately a Xennial on the cusp of the millennials. In the 1990s we were the slackers. This was the Reality Bites, Kurt Cobain, nobody-wants-to-wash-their-hair era. We were supposedly cynical, disengaged, light on ambition and not really interested in following the rules about work and careers.
Then the millennials arrived and became the problem, with their supposed appetite for constant praise and promotions they hadn’t earned. Now it’s Gen Z’s turn, and apparently they don’t want to work at all.
It seems every generation develops a terrible work ethic just as it enters the workforce, which should make us a bit suspicious. The research confirms this is a very real phenomenon.
A large international study published in the Journal of Business and Psychology analysed data from 584,217 people across 113 countries and found that work motivation was more closely linked to age and the period people were living through than to the generation they belonged to. A 22-year-old in their first professional job will have different priorities from a 45-year-old with a mortgage and two decades of experience. That’s a difference in stage of life, rather than a character trait.
Of course, some young employees are difficult to manage or unprofessional. I’ve worked with plenty of older people who fit that description too. Poor performance isn’t a generational trait, and it’s unfair to take the behaviour of a few individuals and use it to judge millions of young people, particularly when the “judges” got the same treatment at that age.
A harder start than we admit
Underneath the “lazy” label is an assumption that starting a corporate or white-collar career works the way it used to - get a degree, find a decent job. It really doesn’t.
The 2025 Graduate Outcomes Survey found that 75.4% of recent Australian undergraduates were in full-time work four to six months after finishing their studies. That sounds encouraging on the surface, but dig a little deeper and you’ll find that the share working in full-time professional or managerial roles fell from 72.3% in 2016 to 67.3% in 2025, and nearly one in three graduates said they felt overqualified for their work. In short: graduates are finding jobs, just not always ones that use the skills they spent years and a lot of money studying.
Even with a job, security isn’t guaranteed. Monash University’s 2025 Australian Youth Barometer surveyed 527 Australians aged 18 to 24 and found that 85% had experienced financial insecurity in the previous year. Housing is enormously expensive and the cost of living worries all of us.
So when a young employee asks about pay, or how quickly they can progress, maybe “entitlement” isn’t the first word we should reach for. They may simply be working out how to afford a decent life in an economy they had no part in creating.
Experience has to be built somewhere
Looking back at my own early career, I learned so much from doing the basic tasks junior people are given. I did a lot of admin despite having a media degree. I didn’t get everything right the first time, and someone more senior would review my work and help me improve. That’s how most of us learned to do our jobs.
AI can now do many of those tasks in a fraction of the time, and we have some pretty mixed evidence on what that means for junior employment. Stanford analysis and research discussed by the London School of Economics suggest that employment among younger workers in some AI-exposed occupations (meaning, white-collar roles) has weakened relative to other groups, and that some employers using generative AI are slowing junior recruitment rather than laying people off.
SEEK’s Australian analysis paints a more varied picture. It found many professional occupations are more exposed to AI augmentation than automation, and in some the share of ads suitable for early-career workers has actually risen. I’d conclude from that that AI may change what junior work looks like, without eliminating it across the board.
However, the risk is real enough to take seriously. Junior tasks can look unimportant if you assess them purely on efficiency, but they’re how people learn. Companies will still need experienced managers and specialists, and those people don’t arrive fully formed. If we automate the learning without replacing it, I’m not sure where the next generation of experienced professionals comes from. So far I haven’t heard employers who are cutting junior roles tell us how they plan to deal with that.
The same logic applies to the complaint that young people turn up without the right skills, like knowing how to write a professional email or behave in a client meeting. Of course they don’t know. Nobody does until someone shows them. I didn’t know everything when I started, and I doubt many of the people making this complaint did either.
It’s also worth bearing in mind that many members of Gen Z lost important years of school or university to the pandemic, with fewer chances to build confidence in professional and social settings as things were done online. It’s a little unfair to complain young employees lack experience, taking into account the fewer opportunities they’ve had to gain it.
What Gen Z has right
Then there’s work-life balance, where I think Gen Z has it right and the rest of us took far too long.
The corporate culture a lot of us grew up in treated long hours as a badge of honour. First in and last out was how you showed commitment, and being available whenever the business needed you was part of the deal, even if it cost you your weekends or time with your family. The expectation only got stronger the more senior you became. I’ve spent a lot of time around corporate leaders, and I’ve seen how easily excessive hours become normal. People get so used to being busy and constantly available that they stop noticing how much of their lives they’ve handed over to work.
We really can’t be surprised when Gen Z looks at that and wonders why they should make the same sacrifices. Deloitte’s 2025 Australian research found that 94% of Gen Z respondents prioritised meaningful work, while only 7% prioritised reaching a senior leadership position. I don’t read that as a lack of ambition; to me it looks more like a challenge to the idea that career success means climbing as high as you can.
In fact, I know plenty of people in their 40s and 50s who are questioning whether they still want corporate life for themselves, and are thinking about changing careers or leaving corporate employment altogether. Gen Z may have simply reached those conclusions earlier.
What we can do differently
Those of us who are established in our careers have some responsibility to improve things. Here are three places to start.
Teach people how to work. It sounds obvious, but it gets overlooked when everyone is busy and under pressure to deliver. Someone starting out can’t have the knowledge of a person with 15 years in the job. That might mean explaining why you approached a problem a particular way, letting a junior sit in on a meeting and talking it through afterwards, or giving feedback that shows them what to do differently next time.
Give managers space to manage. Developing people is part of a manager’s job, and if managers are too overloaded to do it, the organisation has to fix that. We won’t get capable future leaders by expecting inexperienced employees to work everything out themselves.
Redesign junior work around building skills that supplement AI. If AI can draft the first version of a report, a junior employee never learns to research and write it from scratch, so how do they learn to tell whether it’s any good or notice what’s missing? Early-career roles may need rebuilding around that skill, with companies thinking carefully about what people lose when a task disappears.
Stop modelling unhealthy expectations. If you’re a senior manager who tells your team that work-life balance matters but send emails at 11 o’clock at night and expect instant replies, they’ll believe the emails. If you praise people for constant overtime, you’ve told everyone what you value.
Allow people to set healthy boundaries. Someone who sets reasonable boundaries around their working time shouldn’t have their commitment questioned. It’s time we assessed people by the quality of their work and how well they meet their responsibilities. Those of us with more experience have a chance to show that a successful career doesn’t have to revolve around work.
None of this means tolerating poor behaviour or dropping performance standards. It means recognising that experience has to be built, and that employers have a role in building it.
So are we letting Gen Z down at work?
In some important ways, I think we are. We expect young people to build careers in an economy where financial security is hard to come by, while introducing technology that could reshape the traditional pathways into professional work without a clear plan for how they’ll gain the experience they need.
Then there’s our attitude towards work. We criticise Gen Z for questioning workplace expectations that many of us spent years struggling with ourselves. Perhaps we should be listening to them a little more.
These are the people who will eventually be running our companies and deciding what work looks like in the future. Surely it makes sense to invest in helping them become good at it.
So yes - I think we owe Gen Z an apology. Somewhere along the way, we seem to have forgotten that none of us arrived at our first jobs knowing what we were doing. I certainly didn’t. Thankfully, someone gave me the opportunity to make a mistake, learn from it and become better at my job.
I’d like to think we’re capable of extending the same courtesy to the next generation.
One thing I’m thinking about this week
Something interesting happened this week. Yesterday I was invited to meet with a team of senior leaders at a well-known global company (you definitely know it) after they came across one of my social media posts about declining trust between employers and employees. They wanted to talk about what was happening in their own workplace, and they’d specifically asked me to challenge their thinking.
I won’t name the company, but the conversation was a useful reminder that there are companies out there that genuinely care about their people and are trying to do the right thing.
One thing I took away was how difficult it can be to get this right, even when you’re doing many of the things we’ve traditionally associated with being a good employer. As we’re seeing now, transparent communication, regular pay rises and a genuine commitment to employee wellbeing don’t necessarily translate into a happy, engaged workforce - at least, not like it used to.
Gen Z came up in our discussion too, and I left wondering whether we’re still trying to understand younger employees through the lens of what previous generations wanted from work.
The working world has changed so much over the past decade or so, and perhaps our understanding of what makes a good workplace hasn’t kept up with the change. Some of the things that worked ten or fifteen years ago don’t seem to carry the same weight today.
I spend a lot of time writing about what’s wrong with corporate work, so it was such a breath of fresh air to meet leaders who recognise that something isn’t working and genuinely want to understand why.
I came away with more questions than answers, but also a renewed appreciation for how complicated some of these problems are, even when companies have the best intentions.
Support Track Changes On
Track Changes On is ad-free, and I hope to keep it that way. If you enjoy what I’m doing and want to help me see how far I can take it, you can become a paid supporter for $7 a month or $60 a year.
Paid supporters also get a more direct line into what I cover, including sending me your workplace dilemmas, career questions and corporate nonsense for possible discussion in the newsletter, podcast or social content. Plus subscriber-only chats and live events, if that’s your sort of thing!
Things I’ve made (and you can buy)
If you enjoy my content and would like to support my work, here are a few things I’ve created.
🛒 Track Changes On Shop - Coffee mugs and drinkware for corporate rebels
📖 Do Give Up Your Day Job - Guide to corporate exits and transitions to self-employment
Find me elsewhere
📸 Instagram | @ Threads | 🔗 LinkedIn | 📘 Facebook | 🎵 TikTok | ▶️ YouTube










